Skip To Content
Incoming Files
← The Anomaly Log
Case File · CJ-2025-0029

Peer-reviewed study links vanishing 1950s ‘stars’ on Palomar plates to nuclear tests and UFO reports

Date
October 20, 2025
Place
Palomar Observatory, California (1949–1957 sky survey data)
Type
UFO Sightings
Status
Disputed
Record
Documented

On Oct. 20, 2025, the journal Scientific Reports published a study by Stephen Bruehl of Vanderbilt University Medical Center and Beatriz Villarroel of the Nordic Institute for Theoretical Physics that looked at star-like points of light appearing and vanishing on photographic plates from the first Palomar Observatory Sky Survey, taken before Sputnik. Across 2,718 days from November 1949 to April 1957, the authors report that these transients were 45% more likely on dates within one day of an above-ground nuclear test, and that each additional UFO report on a given day matched an 8.5% rise in transients.

According to Sci.News, the authors wrote that the possibility some transients "may represent UAP events in orbit" cannot be ruled out, while also floating a more ordinary idea: that nuclear blasts triggered unknown atmospheric flashes. The paper itself calls the findings correlations, not proof, and notes the effects are small and the data noisy.

Other scientists are unconvinced. Live Science reported that Nigel Hambly of the University of Edinburgh has argued that apparent transients can be dust, scratches or copying flaws visible only on the original glass plates. Michael Garrett of Jodrell Bank said his worry is "the quality of the data," including old UFO reports never checked for validity, and suspected that "with better data, these apparent correlations would go away." Notre Dame physicist Michael Wiescher suggested blast debris in the upper atmosphere could cause brief flashes.

The paper is open access; read it and the critiques side by side.

What's disputed or missing

  • Would inspecting the original glass plates, not scans, make the transients disappear as Hambly suggests?
  • Can a correlation with UFO reports mean much when reports exist for nearly nine days in ten?

Sources

  1. Main
  2. Main
  3. Main
Back To The Log

Declassified · Direct To You

The CJ Dispatch

New Case Files, Episodes, and Books; Sent When Something Surfaces. Never More Than We Have To Say.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.