Skip To Content
Incoming Files
← The Anomaly Log
Case File · CJ-2025-0035

A study claiming shocked quartz at Clovis sites revives the comet-impact theory, then gets retracted

Date
Published Sep 10, 2025; retracted Feb 11, 2026
Place
Murray Springs, Arizona; Blackwater Draw, New Mexico; Arlington Canyon, California
Type
Odd Happenings
Status
Disputed
Record
Documented
Filed Under Hidden History

Did an exploding comet end the Ice Age world of mammoths and the Clovis people about 12,900 years ago? That's the Younger Dryas impact hypothesis, and in September 2025 its backers announced what they called new evidence.

According to UC Santa Barbara's Marine Science Institute, a team led by emeritus professor James Kennett reported in PLOS One that it had found shocked quartz at three key Clovis sites: Murray Springs in Arizona, Blackwater Draw in New Mexico, and Arlington Canyon on California's Channel Islands. The team said electron microscopy confirmed the grains, which sat alongside a carbon-rich "black mat," nanodiamonds and metallic spherules. Kennett said the varying levels of shock fit an airburst rather than a crater-forming impact.

The paper didn't last. Retraction Watch reports that PLOS One retracted it in notices published February 11, 2026, citing missing data, problems with the age model used to date the layer, and no analysis of the sediments above and below. The journal said "it cannot be ruled out" that the markers were not unique to the Younger Dryas layer. A second paper from the same Comet Research Group, on Baffin Bay cores, was retracted at the same time. Lead author Christopher Moore said the group stands by its data and called the problem procedural.

Most geologists and archaeologists were already unconvinced. A 2023 review in Earth-Science Reviews by Vance Holliday, Mark Boslough and others called for the hypothesis to be rejected, noting that no crater of the right age has been found and that the proposed markers are often poorly dated or linked to non-impact processes. Boslough told Retraction Watch that the authors misrepresented critics' work. Both sides' papers are linked below.

What's disputed or missing

  • Will the group republish with the missing data? Its authors say the science is sound, and the dispute now depends on whether anyone can check it.
  • Why has no crater turned up? Supporters say an airburst wouldn't leave one, and critics say that makes the claim hard to test.

Sources

  1. Main
    UCSB Marine Science Institute: New evidence of ancient cosmic impact at key Clovis sites The team's claims, the three sites, and Kennett's airburst explanation
  2. Main
    Astronomy: Did a comet wipe out an ancient civilization? Coverage of the PLOS One shocked-quartz study when it came out
  3. Main
    Retraction Watch: Controversial comet theory struck by two new retractions The Feb 2026 retractions, the journal's reasons, Boslough's criticism and Moore's response
  4. Main
Back To The Log

Declassified · Direct To You

The CJ Dispatch

New Case Files, Episodes, and Books; Sent When Something Surfaces. Never More Than We Have To Say.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.