Liège scientists publish a brain-based model of near-death experiences, and critics push back
- Date
- March 31, 2025
- Place
- Coma Science Group, University of Liège, Belgium
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Disputed
- Record
- Documented
On March 31, 2025, an international team led by Charlotte Martial and Nicolas Lejeune of the University of Liège's Coma Science Group published 'A neuroscientific model of near-death experiences' in Nature Reviews Neurology. They call it NEPTUNE, short for Neurophysiological Evolutionary Psychological Theory Understanding Near-death Experience.
According to the university, the model proposes that an acute crisis such as a sudden loss of blood flow and oxygen to the brain sets off 'a cascade of physiological and psychological reactions'. Serotonin and dopamine systems may shape the visions, while other neurotransmitter systems help lock the experience into memory. It draws on animal studies, psychedelic research and work on the dying brain, and frames NDEs in evolutionary terms. 'We now have sufficient data to propose a coherent framework explaining NDEs,' Martial said.
The paper is a review, not a new experiment. The authors call the model 'theoretical at present', say each mechanism still needs testing, and state that it does not cover features such as precognition. They excluded theories in which consciousness can operate apart from the brain, citing a lack of empirical evidence, so the model does not address survival after death.
That choice drew a response. In January 2026, Bruce Greyson and Marieta Pehlivanova of the University of Virginia's Division of Perceptual Studies, which has studied NDEs for decades, argued in Psychology of Consciousness that NEPTUNE 'selectively ignored scientific evidence that contradicts the model'. They say brain-induced hallucinations usually involve one sense while NDEs are multisensory and remembered for decades, and that brain stimulation has never produced accurate perception of anything not visible.
No proof either way was shown: one side offers a testable framework, the other says it leaves too much unexplained.
What's disputed or missing
- Can NEPTUNE's proposed mechanisms be tested in cardiac-arrest patients? The authors say this work has not yet been done.
- Do verified out-of-body perceptions exist? Critics cite them; the model's authors excluded such claims for lack of evidence.
Sources
-
Main
A neuroscientific model of near-death experiences (Nature Reviews Neurology, author copy) The paper itself: publication date, authors, 'theoretical at present', exclusion of dualistic theories.
-
Main
A new neuroscientific model to explain near-death experiences (GIGA, University of Liège) University summary, NEPTUNE acronym and researcher quotes.
-
Main
New model fails to explain near-death experiences, scientists say (UVA Health) Greyson and Pehlivanova's January 2026 critique.