Vatican rejects appeal by monks banned in Christchurch amid claims of unauthorized exorcisms
- Date
- August 10, 2025
- Place
- Diocese of Christchurch, New Zealand (order based on Papa Stronsay, Orkney, Scotland)
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Concluded
- Record
- Documented
In a letter dated August 10, 2025, Bishop Michael Gielen of Christchurch, New Zealand, told Catholics that the Vatican had "rejected in its entirety" an appeal by the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer. The order calls itself a "congregation of missionary monks" and owns Papa Stronsay, an island off Scotland where it runs a monastery and farm.
According to the Catholic News Agency, Gielen banned the order from public ministry in his diocese in 2024 and announced it in a July 2024 pastoral letter. The ban followed an apostolic visitation, or church inspection, by Australian Bishop Robert McGuckin, and the Vatican recommended the sanctions. The rejected appeal means the ban stands and also covers priests who arrived after the decrees were announced. The community had kept ministering in Christchurch while the appeal was pending.
Gielen's letters did not give the reasons. The Christchurch Press reported that the inquiry concerned "alleged abuse and unauthorized exorcisms," and the New Zealand Herald reported allegations of unlicensed exorcisms in 2023. Neither the diocese nor the Vatican has published findings, CNA did not name the Vatican office involved, and the order gave no direct response in that report. Gielen said his "foremost concern remains the spiritual health and unity" of the diocese.
The allegations remain unproven in public, but the Vatican's refusal to lift the ban is on the record. The CNA and EWTN reports below have the bishop's statements.
What's disputed or missing
- What did the visitation actually find? The church has not released the report or the reasons for the ban.
- Who authorized the exorcisms in question, if anyone? The allegations have been reported, but no details have been confirmed.
Sources
-
Main
EWTN News: Vatican upholds ministry ban on order in New Zealand after alleged abuse, illicit exorcisms Aug 10 letter, appeal rejected, Christchurch Press and NZ Herald allegations, bishop's quotes
-
Main
Catholic World Report (CNA): Vatican allows New Zealand ban on Scottish congregation after alleged illicit exorcisms 2024 ban, McGuckin visitation, order's continued ministry during appeal