Red spots on a communion host in Indiana turn out to be fungus and hand bacteria
- Date
- Feb 21 – Mar 24, 2025
- Place
- St. Anthony of Padua Church, Morris, Indiana
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Explained
- Record
- Documented
In late February 2025, photos of what looked like a bleeding communion host began circulating from St. Anthony of Padua Church in Morris, a small parish in southeastern Indiana.
According to OSV News, consecrated hosts fell to the floor on February 21 and were placed in water in the tabernacle to dissolve. An anonymous young woman said she saw "drops of blood" on two of them, and the next day described one as looking like "a very very thin piece of skin with blood on it." Corpus Christi for Unity and Peace, a Catholic advocacy group in Carmel, Indiana, posted her photos on Facebook and X.
The Archdiocese of Indianapolis confirmed on March 3 that a "careful investigation, with assistance from a professional laboratory, is in progress." Father Terry Donahue, a priest not involved in the case, told OSV News that Vatican rules require a commission with a scientific expert. He also noted that some red mold spores can look like blood to an untrained eye.
On March 24, the archdiocese announced the results. According to Catholic World Report and the Associated Press, the biochemical analysis found a fungus and three bacterial species, all commonly found on human hands. "No presence of human blood was discovered," the archdiocese said, and it concluded the cause was natural and "not miraculous." The lab was not named.
The case shows how these claims are now handled: the church sent the host to a lab first and ruled after. Believers who shared the photos got a clear answer within a month. The original reports are below.
What's disputed or missing
- Which lab ran the tests, and will the full report be released? The archdiocese has given only a summary.
- Will the parish's photos be retired now? The test results answer the question, but the images keep circulating online without them.
Sources
-
Main
Catholic World Report (CNA): Lab results indicate discolored host was 'not miraculous' March 24 announcement: fungus, three bacterial species, no human blood
-
Main
Catholic Review (OSV News): Indianapolis Archdiocese probes parish's alleged Eucharistic miracle Feb 21 timeline, the witness's description, social media spread, Father Donahue's comments
-
Main
ABC News (AP): It was bacteria, not a miracle, on a communion wafer in Indiana church AP report confirming the lab findings