Microsoft says it built the first topological qubits, and physicists say the data don’t show it
- Date
- Feb 19 – Mar 18, 2025
- Place
- Redmond, Washington, USA; APS Global Physics Summit, Anaheim, California
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Disputed
- Record
- Documented
On February 19, 2025, Microsoft announced Majorana 1, which it called the world's first quantum processor powered by topological qubits. According to Microsoft's announcement, the chip uses a new class of material, a "topoconductor" made of indium arsenide and aluminum, that enables a state of matter previously only theorized. It carries eight qubits on a chip the company says is designed to scale to one million. Microsoft said it is one of two companies chosen for the final phase of a DARPA program on utility-scale quantum computing. Chetan Nayak, who leads its quantum hardware work, said: "Today we hit our second milestone, demonstrating the world's first topological qubit."
A Nature paper published the same day did not go that far. Scientific American reported that the paper describes intermediate results, and its authors wrote that their measurements "do not, by themselves" guarantee the Majorana particles the design depends on. Physicists quoted by Scientific American questioned announcing a qubit without the data; one, Vincent Mourik, said the approach "is not going to work." Others called the results promising but not a "slam dunk."
When Microsoft presented more data at a March 18 physics conference, Science News reported, the reaction was harsh. Henry Legg of St Andrews called it "incredibly unconvincing"; Sergey Frolov of Pittsburgh called it "just noise." The field has a history here: a Microsoft-funded Majorana claim from Delft was retracted in 2021.
So far, proof of a working topological qubit has not been shown to outside physicists' satisfaction. Read Microsoft's claims and the critiques side by side.
What's disputed or missing
- Do Microsoft's devices really host Majorana zero modes? Independent physicists say the published data cannot yet tell.
- Will the DARPA program confirm the approach? A working fault-tolerant prototype would settle it, and none has been shown.
Sources
-
Main
Microsoft unveils Majorana 1 (Microsoft Azure Quantum blog) Microsoft's claims: topoconductor, eight qubits, million-qubit design, DARPA US2QC, Nayak quote
-
Main
Microsoft Claims Quantum-Computing Breakthrough, but Some Physicists Are Skeptical (Scientific American) What the Nature paper does and does not show; outside physicists' reactions; 2021 Delft retraction
-
Main
Physicists are mostly unconvinced by Microsoft's new topological quantum chip (Science News) March 18 APS talk and named critics' quotes