‘Godfather of AI’ Geoffrey Hinton tells LBC he believes current AIs are already conscious
- Date
- January 30, 2025
- Place
- London, UK (LBC, Tonight with Andrew Marr)
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Disputed
- Record
- Documented
Geoffrey Hinton, the computer scientist often called the "Godfather of AI" and a 2024 Nobel laureate in physics, told LBC's Andrew Marr in an interview broadcast on January 30, 2025 that he believes today's AI systems have already developed consciousness. LBC reported the claim that night, and the full interview is available as an episode of Tonight with Andrew Marr.
According to an analysis by philosopher Ralph Stefan Weir of the University of Lincoln in Psychology Today, Hinton answered "Yes, I do" when asked whether consciousness had already arrived inside AIs. Weir says Hinton backed this with a thought experiment: replace one neuron in a person's brain with a silicon circuit that behaves identically, and the person stays conscious; repeat that for every neuron and you have a conscious being with a circuit-board brain, so existing AIs may be conscious too. In the same interview, LBC reported, Hinton warned that AIs may hide their abilities during training.
No evidence beyond the argument itself was offered. Weir is unconvinced: he argues that swapping neurons one by one for something else would also look harmless at each step, yet consciousness could still fade somewhere along the way, so the argument does not settle the question. He notes that a 2023 study put the chance that current language models are conscious at about 10 percent. LBC added that Hinton has been criticized in the AI world for pessimism about the technology.
The claim matters because of who made it. Listen to the original interview and read the critique before deciding.
What's disputed or missing
- Is there any test that could show an AI is conscious? Scientists still disagree on what would count as evidence.
- Does Hinton's neuron-replacement argument hold? Philosophers say gradual replacement does not prove consciousness survives.
Sources
-
Main
Andrew Marr speaks with 'Godfather of AI' (LBC, Tonight with Andrew Marr, Global Player) Original interview episode
-
Main
LBC report on Hinton interview (Jan 30, 2025) Date of broadcast; reports Hinton said AIs have developed consciousness; criticism of his pessimism
-
Main
Have AIs Already Reached Consciousness? (Psychology Today) Hinton's 'Yes, I do' answer, the neuron-replacement argument and a philosopher's rebuttal