Skip To Content
Incoming Files
← The Anomaly Log
Case File · CJ-2024-0075

A Vanderbilt physicist says time travel need not create paradoxes, because the traveler forgets

Date
December 12, 2024
Place
Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA
Type
Odd Happenings
Status
Disputed
Record
Documented

The grandfather paradox asks what happens if a time traveler prevents their own birth. On December 12, 2024, Vanderbilt University mathematician-physicist Lorenzo Gavassino published a paper in Classical and Quantum Gravity arguing that, under known physics, the paradox doesn't arise, according to Live Science. A preprint, "Life on a closed timelike curve," had appeared on arXiv earlier in 2024.

The paper imagines a spaceship travelling a closed timelike curve, a path through spacetime that loops back to its own past, in a rotating universe of the kind Kurt Gödel described. Gavassino uses standard quantum mechanics to argue that the ship's energy levels must line up so it returns to exactly its starting state after one loop. As a result, entropy rises and then falls back over the trip, memories are erased, and changes such as aging are undone. "Entropy increase is the reason why we die. What happens when you invert death?" he told Live Science. Irreversible acts become temporary, so nothing can be permanently changed.

Gavassino called his work "the first rigorous derivation" of this self-consistency principle "directly from established physics."

The caveats are big. This is a thought experiment, not a machine. Live Science notes that most physicists doubt closed timelike curves exist in our universe, and Stephen Hawking's 1992 chronology protection conjecture proposes that physics prevents them. The paper suggests only that if such loops existed, they would not break logic. The arXiv preprint is free to read.

What's disputed or missing

  • Can closed timelike curves exist in our universe? General relativity allows them on paper, but no known natural process creates one.
  • Does the result hold outside Gödel's idealized rotating universe? The derivation uses a specific model, and other spacetimes have not been tested.

Sources

  1. Main
    Gavassino, Life on a closed timelike curve (arXiv preprint) The paper's setup, method and conclusions
  2. Main
    Live Science: Physicist claims to have solved the infamous 'grandfather paradox' Journal publication date, quotes and the skeptical context
Back To The Log

Declassified · Direct To You

The CJ Dispatch

New Case Files, Episodes, and Books; Sent When Something Surfaces. Never More Than We Have To Say.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.