Avi Loeb and NASA chief split over whether object 1998 KY26 is a lost Soviet probe
- Date
- Nov 9 – 16, 2026
- Place
- Near-Earth space (orbit of 1998 KY26)
- Type
- Odd Happenings
- Status
- Disputed
- Record
- Documented
A small object that circles the Sun is at the center of an argument between Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb and NASA's administrator. The object, 1998 KY26, is about 36 feet (11 meters) wide, spins roughly once every five and a half minutes, and shows what astronomers call non-gravitational acceleration: a push that the Sun's and planets' gravity doesn't explain, according to Fox News and Newsweek.
Loeb and co-authors Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl of the Initiative for Interstellar Studies argue in a paper posted to arXiv that the object could be Phobos 1, a Soviet Mars probe lost in 1988. They report that a simplified Phobos 1 shape model fit eight light curves, and that sunlight pushing on a cylinder or solar panels could account for the acceleration. They call the match "strongly plausible but presently unproven." Loeb told Newsweek he expects a close look to reveal the label "Made in the U.S.S.R."
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said on Fox & Friends that he had "not seen any evidence to suggest this is a threat to our planet or anything other than an asteroid," Fox News reported. NASA pointed to a 2025 study led by its Center for Near-Earth Object Studies that attributed the motion to solar radiation forces.
Other research cuts both ways. A study in Icarus by Georgia Tech's Korbin Hansen and Masatoshi Hirabayashi found KY26 too warm to keep buried ice, which argues against the "dark comet" idea, according to Futurism. A 2026 study in Astronomy & Astrophysics found its light consistent with a rocky asteroid, Fox News reported. No direct proof of a spacecraft has been shown.
The test is coming: Japan's Hayabusa2 probe is due to reach the object in July 2031. Readers can compare the arXiv paper with the news reports below.
What's disputed or missing
- What is causing 1998 KY26's non-gravitational acceleration? Solar radiation forces are the leading natural explanation, but researchers still disagree on the details.
- Is the object a rocky asteroid or a piece of hardware? Spectral studies point to rock, and the Phobos 1 fit is described by its own authors as unproven.
- Will Hayabusa2 settle it? The probe is not due to reach the object until July 2031.
Sources
-
Main
Feasibility of the Phobos 1 Hypothesis for Dark Comet 1998 KY26 (Hibberd, Crowl, Loeb, arXiv) Primary paper: light-curve and orbit fits, 'strongly plausible but presently unproven' conclusion, July 2031 Hayabusa2 rendezvous
-
Main
Fox News: Near-Earth asteroid 1998 KY26 may actually be Soviet spacecraft Phobos 1 (Nov 12, 2026) Isaacman's Fox & Friends quote, Icarus and Astronomy & Astrophysics findings, Loeb's 'Made in the U.S.S.R.' prediction
-
Main
Fox News: Harvard scientist pushes back on NASA chief over mystery space object (Nov 15, 2026) Loeb's rebuttal, no detected outgassing, NASA's statement citing its 2025 CNEOS-led study
-
Main
Newsweek: Dark comet or Soviet probe? Mystery over origin of unexplained space object (Nov 16, 2026) Summary of the four competing explanations and Loeb's quotes
-
Alt
Futurism: Mysterious object accelerating in space (Nov 9, 2026) Georgia Tech Icarus study (Hansen and Hirabayashi) finding the object too warm to keep buried ice