Skip To Content
Incoming Files
← The Anomaly Log
Case File · CJ-2024-0004

Google’s quantum chief says the Willow chip ‘lends credence’ to parallel universes

Date
December 9, 2024
Place
Google Quantum AI, United States
Type
Odd Happenings
Status
Disputed
Record
Documented
Filed Under Fringe Science

On December 9, 2024, Google announced Willow, a new quantum computing chip, alongside a study in Nature. Google said Willow finished a benchmark task called random circuit sampling in under five minutes, a job it estimated would take one of today's fastest supercomputers about 10 septillion (10^25) years. The company also said the chip reduces errors as it scales up, a long-standing obstacle.

It was a line in the announcement blog post by Hartmut Neven, founder of Google Quantum AI, that went viral. According to TechCrunch, Neven wrote that the result "lends credence to the notion that quantum computation occurs in many parallel universes," in line with physicist David Deutsch's view, rooted in Hugh Everett's 1950s many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Physicists pushed back. The Quantum Insider reported that astrophysicist and science writer Ethan Siegel argued superposition and entanglement can be explained without a multiverse, under interpretations such as Copenhagen or pilot-wave theory, and accused Neven of conflating "a quantum mechanical Hilbert space" with "parallel universes and a multiverse." Other critics noted random circuit sampling is a hardware benchmark Google itself devised, not a practical application, and that, as with Google's 2019 Sycamore result, classical methods may later close the gap.

The mainstream position is that Willow is a real engineering advance, but that its speed is predicted by standard quantum mechanics under any interpretation and offers no direct evidence that other universes exist.

What's disputed or missing

  • Can any experiment distinguish many-worlds from other interpretations? Critics say Willow's results are equally consistent with all of them.
  • Will classical algorithms catch up on the benchmark? That happened partly after Google's 2019 claim.

Sources

  1. Main
  2. Main
    Google Willow quantum chip sparks debate on multiverse theory (The Quantum Insider) Deutsch background and critics including Ethan Siegel
Back To The Log

Declassified · Direct To You

The CJ Dispatch

New Case Files, Episodes, and Books; Sent When Something Surfaces. Never More Than We Have To Say.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.